To build, or not to build – that is the question.
One concern I hear consistently in our community is this: how are our tax dollars being spent, and are we getting our priorities right?
I’m not against arts, culture, recreation or major projects. They all have value. But before we commit millions of dollars, I think we need to ask a simple question:
Do we need it right now, or do we want it right now?
Thunder Bay already has a serious infrastructure challenge. The City has identified an annual infrastructure funding gap of about $30.6 million just to maintain current service levels, along with approximately $1.3 billion in infrastructure considered high or very high risk.
That’s a major financial pressure.
And we’re not just talking about roads. The City is responsible for roads, sidewalks, bridges, culverts, watermains, wastewater and stormwater systems, public facilities, parks, equipment and fleet. Its own asset-management policy says the majority of capital funding should be directed toward renewing existing infrastructure, while considering long-term affordability and lifecycle costs.
At the same time, Thunder Bay is facing other serious pressures – homelessness, housing shortages, public safety concerns, aging infrastructure and increasing costs to deliver everyday municipal services.
All of these needs compete for the same limited pool of public dollars.
That is why strong fiscal responsibility matters.
Major projects can also grow significantly in cost. The Waterfront Art Gallery is one example. Its overall project cost was reported at about $50 million in 2023, while the current fundraising target is approximately $75 million. The City originally committed about $5.7 million, later approved another $2.5 million, and the project has also faced roughly $10 million in additional environmental costs.
That does not mean the project has no value, and municipal taxpayers are not paying the entire cost.
But it does show why we need to carefully evaluate every major investment.
When we already have a $30.6 million annual infrastructure gap, significant infrastructure at elevated risk, housing pressures, homelessness and growing demands on basic services, Council has to be disciplined about priorities.
For every major project, we should be asking:
What will it cost to build?
What will it cost to operate?
What happens if costs increase?
What will taxpayers be responsible for 10 or 20 years from now?
And where does it rank against the needs residents are facing today?
Fiscal responsibility isn’t about saying no to everything.
It’s about recognizing that we cannot fund every want at the same time.
Take care of the basics. Address the biggest pressures. Protect the infrastructure we already have. Then decide what we can responsibly afford to build next.